It’s no secret that Republicans spent a lot of money in the 2026 midterms only to get completely blown out. Yet some of the figures are truly extraordinary. According to AdImpact, 2026 had the most spending of any midterm in history, and even saw more political spending than the 2024 presidential cycle. In addition, Republicans held a significant advantage in total spending, and a slight advantage in airtime. However, despite these advantages, the Republicans got blown out anyway.
Does that mean political spending doesn’t matter? Or does it mean that Republicans (and some Democrats) simply spent their money in alarmingly stupid ways? I would argue that the Republicans did have a misallocation problem. We all saw the eye-popping $300M price tag for Ken Paxton, who lost by 12%. That spending decision likely cost Republicans in Mississippi, Kansas, and Iowa, where Democrats actually managed to outspend their opponents. However, we haven’t had a full reckoning with just how badly NRCC Chair Richard Hudson and the Republican committees did with their funds. Considering Hudson wasn’t even able to beat Richard Ojeda to win his own seat in the end (the second consecutive midterm where this has happened), I’d say he had a rough Election Night.
From the inimitable Rob Pyers’ final sheet of independent expenditures, Republican committees spent at least $4.9M on each of the following 46 seats:
| Dist | Republican Committee spending (rounded to the nearest $10,000) |
|---|---|
| NC01 | $24,980,000 |
| MI07 | $24,910,000 |
| FL14 | $23,450,000 |
| AZ01 | $22,890,000 |
| FL25 | $22,760,000 |
| NY17 | $22,610,000 |
| MI10 | $20,320,000 |
| TX34 | $19,070,000 |
| CO08 | $18,590,000 |
| WA03 | $18,390,000 |
| WI03 | $15,860,000 |
| MI04 | $14,970,000 |
| ME02 | $14,630,000 |
| OH09 | $14,590,000 |
| FL22 | $14,230,000 |
| PA08 | $14,130,000 |
| AZ06 | $14,080,000 |
| PA10 | $13,880,000 |
| CA22 | $13,560,000 |
| PA07 | $13,290,000 |
| TX15 | $13,140,000 |
| IA03 | $12,640,000 |
| VA02 | $12,210,000 |
| MT01 | $11,630,000 |
| TX35 | $11,570,000 |
| PA01 | $10,820,000 |
| NM02 | $10,490,000 |
| NY03 | $10,210,000 |
| WI01 | $10,190,000 |
| NJ07 | $10,180,000 |
| NC11 | $9,890,000 |
| IA02 | $9,810,000 |
| CA13 | $8,880,000 |
| IA01 | $8,540,000 |
| AKAL | $8,490,000 |
| OH07 | $8,390,000 |
| KY06 | $8,050,000 |
| AZ02 | $7,700,000 |
| SC01 | $7,530,000 |
| TX28 | $6,450,000 |
| CO05 | $6,180,000 |
| OH01 | $5,440,000 |
| AL02 | $5,100,000 |
| OH15 | $4,970,000 |
| OH10 | $4,870,000 |
| VA01 | $4,560,000 |
Of these 46 districts, the Republicans won exactly two: ME-02 and Alaska (once ranked-choice is eventually tabulated). And Alaska was only won because too many Dems voted for an out-of-state man in federal prison running on the Democratic label and forgot to rank the Independent.
This is some terrible spending. By my count, this is over $162M spent on seats that were not within 10 pts, and close to $600M overall. In fairness, the Democrats matched this spending as well, pouring in just over $550M, which makes sense since these districts were seen as critical to the majority. However, Democrats will probably rue not spending more in Florida, Tennessee, North Carolina, and Texas districts that were all very close.
That being said, the Republicans clearly doubled down on districts they had no hope of defending, and it cost them another 12-20 incumbents who were left to sink or swim. The collapse of the North Carolina gerrymander, for example, may have been partially due to a total lack of investment on the Republican side. Democrats spent a lot of money to get strong performances from Don Davis and Jamie Ager, but even more seats got dragged along in the tide for people who spent almost nothing.
The Republican House campaigns seemed to be remarkably cavalier about defending seats until the very end, when Trump rushed money to formerly “Safe R” districts that weren’t so safe. If anything, they should’ve been doing this earlier, as modeling and polling showed seats like MO-02 and MN-01 were in danger in such a strong blue wave. However, it seems Republicans were basically praying for a polling error in their favor as late as October, and were still investing money into flipping Democrat-held districts like NM-02 and NY-03 that had zero chance of flipping.
The Democrats optimized their strategy to win 240 seats, but ultimately won 260. Given two-year House cycles, it makes sense that Democrats wanted to buy rather than rent seats, as sources mentioned in an October NYT piece. Dem seats with favorable trends or ones that Harris outright won, such as PA-01, VA-01, NY-17, and PA-10 are more likely to hold for Democrats in the future than Trump +25 TN-04, which will probably be an auto-flip back to a Republican that is less onerous than Scott Desjarlais. The only clear missed opportunities were in ME-02, CO-03, and Alaska At-Large, where some savvier strategies, better candidate quality, and a little more money could have made a big difference. There are, somehow, still flips on the table for Democrats in 2028, in addition to potentially gaining some seats out of redistricting in New York, Maryland, and Wisconsin.
Did spending matter overall?
Yes. It always matters. Both Democrats and Republicans managed to use money to boost certain candidates in the Senate and House. Democrats in particular excelled at using clean energy dark money PACs (yes, an oxymoron) to oust some particularly awful Republican incumbents like Jeff Van Drew (NJ-02) and Lauren Boebert (CO-04) that Republicans could not hope to match.
We also definitely saw the importance of running a very strong statewide ticket to help boost turnout across a state. While many wonder why so much money was spent on Roy Cooper or Sherrod Brown, their strong campaigns helped drive out enough Dem turnout to flip seats on their coattails. I would only add that Dems could have made use of a slightly different strategy to target states where there were no major statewide races occurring, like Missouri and Indiana. In these low-turnout affairs, more money could have helped take out even more Republicans and cause even more pain at the federal and state levels.



